Lock Out
A common clause in a CRE loan agreement. This is the period of time after disbursement that a borrower is not allowed to prepay the loan. Lenders will many times enforce a lock out period along with prepayment penalties after the lock out period as a way to ensure they are receiving earnings off the money they are responsible for disbursing.
Putting “Lock Out” in Context
Case Study: James River Apartments
Old Dominion Realty Partners, a real estate private equity firm, acquired James River Apartments, a 200-unit market-rate multifamily community in Richmond, Virginia, for $30 million. To finance the acquisition, the firm secured a $21 million loan from a regional lender at a 4.5% fixed interest rate with a 30-year amortization schedule. The loan agreement included a five-year lock-out period, during which the borrower could not prepay the loan without significant penalties.
How Lock Out Applies in This Context
The lock-out clause ensured that the lender would receive consistent interest income for a minimum period, protecting its anticipated return on the capital disbursed. For Old Dominion Realty Partners, this clause limited their ability to refinance or pay off the loan early, even if interest rates declined or the property appreciated significantly during the lock-out period.
Key Considerations
- Operational Flexibility: The five-year lock-out period required Old Dominion Realty Partners to carefully assess their long-term investment strategy before agreeing to the loan terms. This was especially critical as refinancing during the lock-out period was not an option, even if market conditions became favorable.
- Prepayment Risk Mitigation: By including the lock-out clause, the lender reduced the risk of early prepayment, ensuring it would recover origination costs and achieve a predictable return on the loan.
- Potential Costs After Lock Out: Once the lock-out period ended, the loan agreement included a step-down prepayment penalty. For example, a penalty of 3% of the remaining loan balance would apply in year 6, decreasing to 2% in year 7, and 1% in year 8.
Implications for Borrower Strategy
The lock-out period aligned with Old Dominion Realty Partners’ planned hold period for James River Apartments, which was projected at 7–10 years. By selecting a loan with terms that matched their investment horizon, the firm minimized the impact of the lock-out clause on their ability to execute their business plan.
However, if the firm’s strategy had shifted—for instance, deciding to sell the property in year 3—they would have faced significant limitations due to the inability to prepay the loan. This underscores the importance of aligning loan terms with the investment’s projected timeline and flexibility needs.
Conclusion
This hypothetical scenario illustrates how lock-out clauses in commercial real estate loans are used to protect lenders while potentially limiting borrower flexibility. By understanding the implications of a lock-out period and incorporating it into their strategic planning, borrowers can make informed decisions that balance financial objectives with operational constraints.
Frequently Asked Questions about Lock Out Clauses in Commercial Real Estate Loans
What is a lock-out clause in a CRE loan?
A lock-out clause is a provision in a commercial real estate loan that prohibits the borrower from prepaying the loan for a set period after disbursement. This protects the lender’s expected interest income.
Why do lenders use lock-out clauses?
Lenders include lock-out clauses to secure a predictable return and recover origination costs by ensuring the borrower doesn’t refinance or repay the loan early, especially during favorable market shifts.
How long do lock-out periods typically last?
Lock-out periods vary, but in the James River Apartments example, the lock-out lasted five years. These periods often align with a portion of the loan term to ensure the lender earns sufficient interest.
What happens after the lock-out period ends?
After the lock-out ends, borrowers may prepay the loan but typically face step-down prepayment penalties. For example, a 3% penalty in year 6, decreasing to 2% in year 7 and 1% in year 8.
How does a lock-out period affect borrower flexibility?
The lock-out limits refinancing or selling options during the restricted period. If Old Dominion Realty Partners had needed to sell in year 3, the lock-out would have prevented early payoff without severe penalties.
How should borrowers plan around lock-out clauses?
Borrowers should align loan terms with their investment horizon. In the James River case, a 5-year lock-out matched the firm’s 7–10 year hold plan, reducing the likelihood of conflict with the clause.
Are lock-out clauses negotiable?
Yes, lock-out clauses may be negotiated during loan origination. However, removing or shortening them may come at the cost of higher interest rates or stricter loan covenants.
Click here to get this CRE Glossary in an eBook (PDF) format.