Tenants in Common (TIC)
An ownership structure whereby two or more individuals may own an equal or unequal undivided share in a property. This partnership structure enables lower income investors the opportunity to purchase more expensive real estate which they otherwise may not have been able to afford individually. However, when mortgaging a property, the lender will also require that all co-tenants share joint liability for the loan, thereby increasing the risk of the TIC structure.
Putting ‘Tenants in Common’ in Context
Sterling Family Investments, a real estate investment firm operated by a family office, recently decided to expand its portfolio by acquiring The Vista at Barton Creek, a modern multifamily apartment complex located in the vibrant city of Austin, Texas. The property features 120 market-rate units, ample amenities, and has consistently maintained high occupancy rates.
Scenario Overview
The property was valued at $36 million, an investment size too substantial for a single member of the Sterling family to shoulder alone. To facilitate the acquisition, the family opted for a Tenants in Common (TIC) ownership structure. This arrangement allowed four family members to participate, each contributing differently according to their financial capabilities. The shares were distributed as follows:
- Alice Sterling: 40%
- Bob Sterling: 30%
- Claire Sterling: 20%
- David Sterling: 10%
This diversified ownership allowed them to pool resources, thereby affording a property that would otherwise be beyond their individual purchasing capabilities.
Financial and Legal Considerations
To finance the purchase, the Sterlings secured a $25 million mortgage. Under the TIC agreement, despite their varied ownership shares, each co-tenant bore joint liability for the mortgage. This meant that each individual was not just responsible for a proportionate share of the debt corresponding to their ownership stake, but potentially for the entire debt, should the other owners fail to meet their financial obligations.
This setup increased the investment’s risk profile, particularly for those with smaller shares, like David, who could be disproportionately affected by default from other co-tenants. However, the family mitigated this risk through a detailed agreement, setting forth clear terms for handling financial responsibilities and default scenarios, which was crucial in maintaining harmony and clarity among the owners.
Economic Implications
From an economic standpoint, the TIC structure enabled the Sterlings to leverage their collective buying power to enter a lucrative market. The property, The Vista at Barton Creek, boasted a net operating income (NOI) of approximately $2.16 million annually, offering an attractive return potential relative to the inherent risks of joint liability.
This scenario is hypothetical and serves to illustrate how a Tenants in Common ownership can be structured in real estate investments, particularly for family offices or groups of investors seeking to pool resources for larger investments. It underscores both the financial flexibility provided by this arrangement and the importance of legal agreements in managing the associated risks.
Frequently Asked Questions about Tenants in Common (TIC)
What is a Tenants in Common (TIC) ownership structure?
A TIC is an ownership structure in which two or more individuals own undivided shares in a property, which can be equal or unequal. Each co-owner has the right to use the entire property, regardless of their ownership percentage.
How does joint liability work under a TIC structure?
Even though ownership shares may differ, all co-tenants in a TIC share joint liability for the property’s mortgage. This means each owner can be held responsible for the full loan amount if other co-tenants default.
Why might investors choose a TIC structure?
TICs allow investors to pool resources and acquire high-value properties that would be unaffordable individually. This structure is particularly attractive to family offices or small groups seeking access to institutional-grade real estate.
What are the risks of investing through a TIC structure?
The main risk is joint liability for debt, which can expose a smaller investor to significant financial risk if others default. The complexity of decision-making among co-owners can also be a challenge without clear agreements.
How can TIC investors manage the risks of joint ownership?
Through detailed legal agreements that define each owner’s financial responsibilities, procedures for handling defaults, and dispute resolution mechanisms, TIC investors can protect their interests and minimize potential conflicts.
Can ownership shares in a TIC be unequal?
Yes, TIC ownership allows for unequal ownership shares, as shown in the scenario where Alice, Bob, Claire, and David Sterling owned 40%, 30%, 20%, and 10%, respectively.
What kind of properties are commonly acquired through TICs?
TICs are often used to acquire larger, income-producing real estate assets such as apartment complexes, office buildings, or commercial centers—properties typically out of reach for individual investors.
Click here to get this CRE Glossary in an eBook (PDF) format.